As a dating coach, I sometimes have mixed feelings about what I learn in my job: On the one hand, I’m glad people feel comfortable enough with me to ask the questions they may not want to share broadly or ask their friends/family. And, on the other hand, well, sometimes I wish I didn’t know what goes on in the darkest depths of someone’s mind as it relates to their dating lives or other people. This is one of those circumstances.

Question I received:

“How do I politely tell the girl I'm seeing that she needs to lose weight?”

My, perhaps indelicate, response was this:

“‘How do I politely tell you that this is such a disgusting question?’

"Unless you are her medical provider, you don't.

"If your interest in her is contingent on her weight, please end things. For the sake of both of you.

"She has a mirror. She knows what she looks like. But she doesn't have to lose weight. Someone will love her exactly as she is. Sadly, that someone is not you. And if she does lose weight, it will be her choice, not because the person she's dating—the one who is supposed to like her for her—only wants her at a certain size.

"We take people as they come. And assume that how they are now is how they will continue. Then we accept that or not.”

I know this is a sensitive topic for many, and as much as I wanted to be kinder in my response, especially since someone had felt comfortable enough asking me (albeit anonymously), I had a difficult time doing that. When we meet someone, that is the person they are.

Can people change in the future? Sure. But to only be with someone contingent on them making a change that you deem acceptable is not a reason to be with someone.

This question reminded me of a different yet related question recently asking this: “He treats me SO amazingly but doesn’t have much direction in life (he’s 35). Do I wait and hope?”

And my response was similar:

“The person you meet now is the person you are going to get. If you are happy with him just as he is, continue dating him. But if you only want to date him contingent on waiting and hoping for something to happen that will likely not, please don’t.

"The true question to ask yourself is this: Can I be happy with this person assuming they stay exactly as they are, direction in life or otherwise? If the answer is no, it’s a sign to reconsider the relationship. Hoping for someone to change is a gamble—one that’s unfair to both of you.”

There is, of course, some nuance here. As important as it is to believe that the person you meet is the person who they are going to be, what if changes occur while you are in a relationship—weight loss or gain, a newfound lack of motivation, or something else? As comfort sets into a relationship, sometimes changes can—and do—happen.

At that point, there is room to discuss this perceived change with your partner. Rather than accusing someone of "getting worse,” instead, come from a place of curiosity. “Is everything OK? I noticed that you haven’t seemed as motivated lately when it comes to work? Do you want to talk about it?” Then you can have a more collaborative conversation rather than one where your partner feels that your interest is contingent on who they were before.

Everyone will have a set of “perceived flaws,” or subjective things that you would not prefer. Which ones can you live with and which ones can’t you? That’s up to you to decide. Because, in the end, while we can support our partners in their growth, any change must come from their own desire, not our demands.

©2025 Tribune Content Agency, LLC