Entertainment

/

ArcaMax

'Disclaimer' review: Thriller series from Cuarón, Blanchett seduces, frustrates

Mark Meszoros, The News-Herald (Willoughby, Ohio) on

Published in Entertainment News

Disclaimer: A day after finishing “Disclaimer” — after sleeping on it — I’m still not entirely sure how I feel about the highly anticipated Apple TV+ limited series.

Debuting this week with the first two of its seven hourlong chapters, it is an adaptation of the 2015 novel of the same name by Renée Knight.

Second disclaimer: I know nothing of Knight’s work.

I do, however, know the work of the two most noteworthy people involved with this small-screen endeavor: its creator, Alfonso Cuarón, the writer and director of every episode, and its star, Cate Blanchett, who also serves as one of its executive producers.

Since 2001, Cuarón has made five acclaimed films: “Y tu mamá también,” “Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban,” “Children of Men,” “Gravity” and “Roma.” They are as varied as they are interesting, and he won the Academy Award for best director for the latter two. This is a man who knows what he’s doing within the frame.

And then there’s the similarly extremely talented Blanchett, an Oscar winner herself for 2004’s “The Aviator” and 2013’s “Blue Jasmine,” whose other Academy Award-nominated performances include 1998’s “Elizabeth,” 2015’s “Carol” and 2022’s “Tár,” a film I absolutely loved.

Knowing only of the involvement of these two giants, you would expect “Disclaimer” to be excellent — which it is … at points and for stretches.

Highly cinematic even for a prestige TV drama, “Disclaimer” is engaging and can be quite potent, as its nebulous tale of secrets and lies unfolds in calculated measurements portioned out by Cuarón. And, not surprisingly, it boasts some excellent work by Blanchett, backed by a supporting cast that includes fellow veteran actors Kevin Kline and Lesley Manville, as well as a decidedly un-Borat-like Sacha Baron Cohen.

“Disclaimer” also can be melodramatic and even a little silly — at least for something with these kinds of artists behind it. And it mixes in a few sexually charged scenes that while certainly titillating also feel a bit excessive. (The TV-MA-rated series appropriately comes with a content warning.)

Blanchett portrays the dramatically named Catherine Ravenscroft, whose award-winning work as a documentarian has exposed the misdeeds of others. Her life, which includes husband Robert (Baron Cohen, “Sweeney Todd,” “Hugo”) and underachieving adult son Nicholas (Kodi Smit-McPhee, “The Power of the Dog”), is thrown into disarray after she receives a novel, “The Perfect Stranger.”

Dedicated “To my son, Jonathan,” its early pages also contain the all-important disclaimer: “Any resemblance to persons living or dead is not a coincidence.”

It takes little reading for Catherine to realize she is the book’s titular character, whom the author blames for their son’s death.

The viewer soon learns the book has been published under a nom de plume by retired teacher Stephen Brigstocke after finding the work of his late wife, Nancy (Manville, “Phantom Thread," "The Crown"), in the room of their deceased son, Jonathan.

Along with it, he finds explicit photographs taken by Jonathan (Louis Partridge, “Enola Holmes”), right before his death in 2001, of a beautiful woman, believed to be a younger Catherine (Leila George, “Animal Kingdom”). Stephen intends to use both the book and the photographs to destroy Catherine, getting them into the hands of those where they could do the most damage.

For instance, Robert knows nothing about Catherine’s experience those many years ago with Jonathan, during a vacation to an Italian beach.

Robert had to go home early due to work responsibilities, but a young Nicholas remained with his mother. That she did what she did only feet from the boy, if seemingly out of his view, only serves to amplify the anger and disgust Robert comes to direct at Catherine.

 

I don’t want to say much more about the story, for much of the enjoyment of watching “Disclaimer” comes from trying to determine what to take from its myriad flashback sequences, both before Jonathan’s death and after it, when a shell-shocked Nancy decides to move into her dead son’s room and has little more than the necessary dealings with her husband.

I will say — and this could be seen as a strength or weakness of the series — that it becomes difficult to know if you should be rooting for anyone involved. No one is all that likable, and, having finished it, I believe the series would have benefited from Nicholas having something that resembled an appealing quality. It is entirely too hard to care that much if something horrible befalls him, which is a problem.

While Blanchett does the heavy lifting throughout the series, Kline (“A Fish Called Wanda,” “The Big Chill”) is commanding in his scenes. However, the character of Stephen simply can be a bit much — like the series overall.

Rest assured, “Disclaimer” saves something impactful for its finale, an hour of TV that, like the nearly six hours that precede it, is at times engrossing and at others frustrating.

Based on the trappings of the screen version of this psychological thriller, I can’t help but wonder if Knight’s book is little more than a guilty pleasure, the kind of book the younger Catherine may have devoured on that picturesque beach in Italy.

On the other hand, Blanchett in the series’ production notes says she wanted people to be able to rewatch “Disclaimer” and have a different perspective the second time through it.

Final disclaimer: I have not had time to revisit more than the opening minutes of “Disclaimer,” during which an otherwise superfluous character presents a valuable nugget to keep in mind as you watch what follows.

And yes, even with its faults, I’m considering giving the entire series another look.

———

‘DISCLAIMER’

2.5 stars (out of 4)

Rating: TV-MA

How to watch: On Apple TV+ Oct. 11

———


©2024 The News-Herald (Willoughby, Ohio). Visit The News-Herald (Willoughby, Ohio) at www.news-herald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus